July 1, 2006

Why Was Pride So Boring?

The Twin Cities Pride Festival was chock full of corporate goodness. Big box retailers, insurance companies, real estate agents, radio stations, etc. I didn't see the parade, but I can only assume it was hours of advertising for companies who 'support' the GLBT community.

The Star Tribune in the past week has printed to articles about Pride and it's corporatization. In "Gay pride parade an attractive marketplace for businesses", the Strib interviews some gays to ask what they think of the Pride Parade. Each one seems happy that each year there are fewer drag queens and naked guys in barrels (Naked Minnesota), or less of the 'silly glitter element' as Kirby Moore is quoted as saying. Apparently, a boring GLBT Pride is okay for some folks, probably the same type of people that think the Castro, the center of sexual liberation, should be child friendly.

Claude Peck and Rick Nelson banter back and forth in "Withering Glance: The Twin Cities GLBT Pride Festival" about the absolute dullness of Twin Cities Pride suggesting maybe we should call it "Twin Cities GLBT Marketing Opportunity." Where are the strange, sexy, outrageous, and fabulous elements of our community?

Claude says, "Gays and lesbians kvetch that the news media focus only on drag queens and Dykes on Bikes in covering the parade. But those are what are known as vibrant visuals. A phalanx of 75 people in matching Best Buy T-shirts does not exciting television make. Besides, weren't drag queens and dykes the ones who got the whole late-June pride thing going in the first place?"

I'm pretty sure they were. But corporate sponsors don't attach their names to butch, topless womyn on Harley Davidsons, or gaudy contingents of men in hag drag, or buff and tan 20 year olds in hot pants, or aging leather dadddies in harnesses. And the hetero (and gay) families that come down to see the "Gay Parade" would definitely pick up the phone and call to complain if they did.

Nevermind that the 'glitter element' might actually serve to educate people coming to our festival with an open mind, wanting to learn more about GLBT people and culture. Instead they get the message that GLBT people are exactly like them, except they spend a lot of money. The 'glitter element' is part of our history, and we should stop hiding it in favor of corporate sponsorship. Plus the 'glitter element' is fun. Twenty-five people wearing the same t-shirt is boring.

Posted by Andy at July 1, 2006 11:02 AM

Comments

re: The glitter element.

I didn't watch the parade - I was in it.

I was part of the genderBLUR contingent and I can honestly tell you that we were neither corporate-sponsored nor boring.
We had drag queens, kings, stilters, puppets, and rollerfolks.

Perhaps we were in the minority?

The whole point of our float was remembrance of those who came before us, visibility, and transformation.

I was frustrated by the number of folks that I knew who skipped out on the parade because they needed to sleep in due to partying too hard the night before. Even worse, I suppose would be skipping due to apathy (or preconceived notions of corporate take-over).

I skipped because of apathy or preconcieved notions of corporate take-over...

Maybe next year you can organize a Precision Buggery Drill team to amuse the crowd...non corporate sponsored of course.

On the flipside, a lot of the people representing their company in the parade are proud to have an employer who so openly supports them and offers benefits. If I hadn't been driving KFAI's pickup (we'll definitely have something better next year) I would have been on my bike with the other members of my Red Ribbon Ride team from Wells Fargo.

I agree it doesn't make for the most interesting parade ever, but isn't it a little cynical to dismiss it all as pandering to the gay crowd? Face it, this is still the Midwest--we're not all going to magically sprout sequins and sweat glitter just because it's Pride.

I agree with you Jeremy. I do think corporate sponsorship and participation are important. Big business has been a great ally of GLBT people, mostly because we buy things.

I'm just saying I'd like to see more 'roots' of GLBT history, some of the culture.

what i found disturbing was the booth giving away bibles. i asked a pride board member about it and was told that they will not deny anyone a space in the park. so, if the minnesota family council or fred phelps wanted to have a booth to spew anti-gay hate, they would allow it.

As a former board member, I can tell you that Phelps would never be permited to get a booth as they would not follow the rules setup by the Pride Board. Just handing out bibles is not a bad thing. As long as they follow the rules the Pride Board will not discriminate against anyone. However, if this group is the one I think it is, they have had a booth at Pride for several years now. They have always show respect toward people even if they don't think being gay is correct. If they were not respectful towards you or you saw them being disrespectful, I'm sure the Pride Board would get rid of them as they have violated their contract.

Now the real problem is if anyone will tell the Pride Board. The Pride Board hold public meetings all year round and maybe 1 or 2 meetings will anyone outside of the board even come to voice an opinion.

I've mixed feelings about Pride corporatization. I enjoyed the parade this year, but that was about all. I spent most of Sunday wandering around Loring Park but I might as well have gone to a trade show at the Convention Center. The only redeeming experience was running into some old friends. The park was dull!! At the very least I was expecting to enjoy some live music at one of the four stages. Perhaps I was always in the wrong place, but all I found were empty stages playing prerecorded music or nothing at all. The only place that people seemed to be having fun was at the beer garden but I was with my mother and she wasn't interested.

"They have always show respect toward people even if they don't think being gay is correct." ???

How fucked up is that???

re: corporations

Its the corporations who have been on the for-front of granting us benefits and working with local goverments to write them into laws.

re: handing out bibles

So just because these folks are handing out bibles you want them banned?!?! Wow ... that comment is disturbing. Who else do you want to ban just because you don't agree with them?

re: parade/pride

The only advantage of the pride is that it brings everyone out of the woodwork for the weekend. Personally i don't believe the parade or the parkgrounds hold much of value. I skip the parade, visit my company's booth and then I go home.

tim - the bible is the only weapon the right-wing has to justify their efforts to keep us from having full civil rights. personally i would want quite a few groups banned, i.e. Focus on the Family, Exodus International, the KKK, etc. pride is supposed to celebrate our very existence. most of us put up with that bullshit on a daily basis - we shouldn't have to be subjected to it at our community's celebration.

>>the bible is the only weapon the right-wing has to justify their efforts to keep us from having full civil rights

This comment makes little sense. The bible is not their only weapon. They are using all sorts of tactics to try to push us back in the closet. The bible is also our weapon against them.

In addition - a group giving out bibles is no threat to "our community's celebration". The problem I have with your comment is that it assumes that something that one finds insulting or "hurts feelings" should be banned.

Tim - I never said the group was a "threat" to anything or anyone. Just because I say I don't want to see something, doesn't mean it will go away. But I have every right to express my opinion. It's called freedom of speech and I find it disturbing that anyone would deny someone else that right.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Recent News

Corporations Court Gays, Pioneering Social Worker Passes Away: The Pioneer Press looks at corporations actively recruiting LGBT workers. "When he was preparing for his job hunt last year,...
** Sep 24, 2007 **

Iran President: 'No Homosexuals in Our Country': AmericaBlog has more....
** Sep 24, 2007 **

Get Ready for Another Marriage Amendment Push: The social conservatives' buzz over the Iowa court decision striking down that state's Defense of Marriage Act continues in Minnesota...
** Sep 20, 2007 **

Religious Infringement Is Basis of Suit Against Minneapolis: An organizational psychologist contracted by the Minneapolis Police Department filed a federal civil rights suit against the city of Minneapolis...
** Sep 19, 2007 **

South Central Minnesota Pridefest: Last weekend (September 7-8, 2007) was South Central Minnesota Pridefest in Mankato, Minn, and it was a good example of...
** Sep 18, 2007 **

ACLU Comes to the Aid of Sen. Craig: The ACLU has filed a friend-of-the-court brief in support of Sen. Larry Craig's move to have his guilty plea to...
** Sep 18, 2007 **

Local Airport Restroom Becomes a Tourist Attraction: The restroom in the Lindbergh terminal at the Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport where Sen. Larry Craig was arrested in June...
** Sep 17, 2007 **

As Iowa Shows, Marriage is Important to Both Sides of Debate: On August 30th, a Polk County, Iowa, judge ruled that the Defense of Marriage Act in that state was not...
** Sep 15, 2007 **

Friday Music Video: Britney Spears: The Today Show's Matt Lauer has the hard hitting report on Spears' performance at the MTV Music Awards, a performance...
** Sep 14, 2007 **

The Story That Won't Die: News Keeps Sen. Larry Craig in the Hot Seat: Sen. Larry Craig's arrest in the now infamous Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport restroom continues to make news as the senator...
** Sep 11, 2007 **

Search


Favorites

Pam's House Blend
The Shane Life
Jesus' General
Damn Straight
Wayne Besen
AMERICAblog
5 o'clock bot
Keith Boykin
Andymatic
PageOneQ
Addy Free
Towleroad
Dan Renzi
Law Dork
Dunner

Queer Blogs

Zionide
Qweerty
Lloydletta
Boy's Brief's
Jasper Ridge
ExGayWatch
Margaret Cho
Good As You
Box Turtle Bulletin
Straight, Not Narrow

MN Politics

MN Campaign Report
A Bluestem Prairie
The Power Liberal
Minnesota Politics
Craig Westover
Dump Bachmann
Norwegianity
Pharyngula
Blanked Out
Minvolved
MN Publius
Blotter

Politics

Agonist
Atrios
WI No on the Amendment
Daily Kos
Andrew Sullivan
Talking Point Memo
Talk Left
Wonkette

The Arts

Arts Nation

Gossip

Gawker
Whatevs

Media

Star Tribune
CityPages
Lavender Mag

Blog Tools

Blogarama - The Blog Directory
Listed on Blogwise
Vote for this site at Freedom Forum
listed on queerfliter
Rate me at TheGayMaleBody.com


Subscribe with Bloglines


Powered by
Movable Type 4.01

Syndicate this site (XML)

Valid CSS!

Support

mnplan03.jpg

Other Projects

Disclaimer

Andy Birkey is a participant in the Center for Independent Media New Journalism Pilot Program. However, all of the statements, opinions, policies, and views expressed on this site are solely Andy Birkey's. This web site is not a production of the Center, and the Center does not support or endorse any of the contents on this site.

Me

Categories
Praise

"Andy is witty, funny, and gay and lives on Eleventh Avenue South." - Twin Cities Babelogue at CityPages

"Witty guys from Minnesota rock." - Dan Renzi

"Andy is proof that good things do come from the middle of the United States." - Fear This Factor

"Eleventh Avenue South is the most read gay Minnesota blog I know of." - Lloydletta's Nooz and Comments

"Andy is the center of the Minnesota (homo) blogosphere." - Opendoors

"I would most likely have an enormous crush if we didn't live appoximately one million zillion kilometres from each other; but we do, so I don't." - Surly Snobby