November 13, 2006

State Auditor Elect Regrets Marriage Amendment Vote

Rebecca Otto, Minnesota's next State Auditor, told the CityPages last week that she regretted her vote for the Marriage Amendment as a member of the Minnesota House in 2004. Bloggers and Green Party candidate Dave Berger made an issue of the vote during the campaign, using the vote to cast a shadow on Otto's support for all Minnesotans.

Otto won her seat in the Minnesota legislature during a special election in 2003, and voted to put an amendment to end domestic partnerships, and ban civil unions and same-sex marriage on the ballot. Back then she told Hometownsource that she voted for the "marriage amendment" because she believed that's what the majority of her constituents wanted. Her former house district resides in the senate district formerly occupied by Michele Bachmann, the marriage amendment's chief author and most vocal proponent.

Later, discussing the vote with GLBT community members, she would not say whether she would personally vote for the measure if it were on the ballot.

She has recently stated publicly that she regretted that vote, including during her attempt at reelection in 2004 which she lost to conservative Republican Matt Dean. She even campaigned in this year's GLBT Pride Twin Cities Pride Parade. In a video on the CityPages blog, The Blotter, Otto had this to say about her vote:

CP: Your vote in the legislature against gay marriage, if you had to do it over again? Otto: Yeah, it would be a different vote because people felt very hurt by my vote, and I never meant to hurt anybody. And I actually publicly annouced before my election in 2004 that I regretted it publicly, and it may have cost me the election, but i regretted it. And the Greens have actually done some dirty campaigning [on the issue]...Hopefully it's not going to cost us.

It didn't cost her, and she won handily last Tuesday. Otto is not the first progressive politician to vote the wrong way on the controversial issue of same-sex relationships; Paul Wellstone voted for the Defense of Marriage Act in the US Senate, and deeply regretted that vote. For those in the GLBT community who may have felt they held their nose to vote for Rebecca Otto, perhaps her statements of regret for casting that vote will regain her some trust as Minnesota's new State Auditor.

Posted by Andy at November 13, 2006 9:02 AM

Comments

Good for her for being upfront about this.

For whatever its worth, it did cost her my vote.

Let the healing begin.

Yeah, I agree with the statement above. She lost my vote this time but I'm open to her changing her stance on the issue.

I voted for her anyway. It was nice to hear her say all that. And refreshing.

I voted for her because Pat Anderson was cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs--"nonessential service", my gay ass.

Even if Rebecca turns out to be not-so-gay friendly, it's not as if Pat was a champion of gay rights--in that respect, we lose nothing and still gain a state auditor who can count without using her fingers and toes.

Along the same lines as a thread I saw on MNpublius...

We don't necessarily hold DOMA against Clinton, nor against the memory of Paul Wellstone. I see that side of the argument. However, she then proceeded to go on TV with an ad that began, "I'm Rebecca Otto, and I live my values." The ad addresses environmental issues (yes, not even the Green candidate makes his own wind energy), however, I took issue with that opening statement. In other interviews (and in a reply to my personal email asking her about it), she states that she voted for the marriage amendment to the Republicans wouldn't have that as a wedge issue against her for re-election. Her exact words to me were, "My vote was my refusal to let the republicans put me in their message box.".

If she felt strongly against the marriage amendment, but voted for it due to political expediency, then I have trouble with her claim that she lives her values. Nor do I think pointing it out was "dirty campaigning".

(Kudos for the windmills though.)

That all said, it didn't cost her my vote per se -- Dave Berger had it to begin with. So maybe I'm biased. But in any case I'm not at all upset she got the job. And this whole thing is moot anyway, the state suditor will not be addressing gay marriage or the lack thereof.

I fail to see how pointing out a candidates anti-gay voting record qualifies as "dirty politics." If Otto didn't want this issue in the campaign, perhaps she should have thought twice before blythely tossing our rights in the trash like a used political tissue.

Her current "whoopsie" will not gain my trust. NO politician, no matter how much we may like them, should win our trust as we learned with Wellstone, who incidentally, never changed his position on gay marriage. In his book, he said he "still wonders" if he did the right thing in voting for DOMA. Translated, he was still pretty satisfied that voting queers into second class citizenship was ok. That's a far cry from "deep regret."

If Otto gets in front of the cameras in January and urges the legislature to pass a law ensuring equal marriage rights for same sex couples in Minnesota because it will, among other things, contribute to the states economic health, I may become a believer.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Recent News

Corporations Court Gays, Pioneering Social Worker Passes Away: The Pioneer Press looks at corporations actively recruiting LGBT workers. "When he was preparing for his job hunt last year,...
** Sep 24, 2007 **

Iran President: 'No Homosexuals in Our Country': AmericaBlog has more....
** Sep 24, 2007 **

Get Ready for Another Marriage Amendment Push: The social conservatives' buzz over the Iowa court decision striking down that state's Defense of Marriage Act continues in Minnesota...
** Sep 20, 2007 **

Religious Infringement Is Basis of Suit Against Minneapolis: An organizational psychologist contracted by the Minneapolis Police Department filed a federal civil rights suit against the city of Minneapolis...
** Sep 19, 2007 **

South Central Minnesota Pridefest: Last weekend (September 7-8, 2007) was South Central Minnesota Pridefest in Mankato, Minn, and it was a good example of...
** Sep 18, 2007 **

ACLU Comes to the Aid of Sen. Craig: The ACLU has filed a friend-of-the-court brief in support of Sen. Larry Craig's move to have his guilty plea to...
** Sep 18, 2007 **

Local Airport Restroom Becomes a Tourist Attraction: The restroom in the Lindbergh terminal at the Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport where Sen. Larry Craig was arrested in June...
** Sep 17, 2007 **

As Iowa Shows, Marriage is Important to Both Sides of Debate: On August 30th, a Polk County, Iowa, judge ruled that the Defense of Marriage Act in that state was not...
** Sep 15, 2007 **

Friday Music Video: Britney Spears: The Today Show's Matt Lauer has the hard hitting report on Spears' performance at the MTV Music Awards, a performance...
** Sep 14, 2007 **

The Story That Won't Die: News Keeps Sen. Larry Craig in the Hot Seat: Sen. Larry Craig's arrest in the now infamous Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport restroom continues to make news as the senator...
** Sep 11, 2007 **

Search


Favorites

Pam's House Blend
The Shane Life
Jesus' General
Damn Straight
Wayne Besen
AMERICAblog
5 o'clock bot
Keith Boykin
Andymatic
PageOneQ
Addy Free
Towleroad
Dan Renzi
Law Dork
Dunner

Queer Blogs

Zionide
Qweerty
Lloydletta
Boy's Brief's
Jasper Ridge
ExGayWatch
Margaret Cho
Good As You
Box Turtle Bulletin
Straight, Not Narrow

MN Politics

MN Campaign Report
A Bluestem Prairie
The Power Liberal
Minnesota Politics
Craig Westover
Dump Bachmann
Norwegianity
Pharyngula
Blanked Out
Minvolved
MN Publius
Blotter

Politics

Agonist
Atrios
WI No on the Amendment
Daily Kos
Andrew Sullivan
Talking Point Memo
Talk Left
Wonkette

The Arts

Arts Nation

Gossip

Gawker
Whatevs

Media

Star Tribune
CityPages
Lavender Mag

Blog Tools

Blogarama - The Blog Directory
Listed on Blogwise
Vote for this site at Freedom Forum
listed on queerfliter
Rate me at TheGayMaleBody.com


Subscribe with Bloglines


Powered by
Movable Type 4.01

Syndicate this site (XML)

Valid CSS!

Support

mnplan03.jpg

Other Projects

Disclaimer

Andy Birkey is a participant in the Center for Independent Media New Journalism Pilot Program. However, all of the statements, opinions, policies, and views expressed on this site are solely Andy Birkey's. This web site is not a production of the Center, and the Center does not support or endorse any of the contents on this site.

Me

Categories
Praise

"Andy is witty, funny, and gay and lives on Eleventh Avenue South." - Twin Cities Babelogue at CityPages

"Witty guys from Minnesota rock." - Dan Renzi

"Andy is proof that good things do come from the middle of the United States." - Fear This Factor

"Eleventh Avenue South is the most read gay Minnesota blog I know of." - Lloydletta's Nooz and Comments

"Andy is the center of the Minnesota (homo) blogosphere." - Opendoors

"I would most likely have an enormous crush if we didn't live appoximately one million zillion kilometres from each other; but we do, so I don't." - Surly Snobby