Time magazine requested Focus on the Family's head, James Dobson, to give a reaction to expecting lesbian couple Mary Cheney and Heather Poe. He did, and it's made him look like a fool. He plagiarized portions of his article.
Even worse, both scientists' research he cited have come out with scathing remarks for Dobson for his (intentional) misinterpretations of their research. NYU Professor Carol Gilligan:
I am writing to ask that you cease and desist from quoting my research in the future. I was mortified to learn that you had distorted my work this week in a guest column you wrote in Time Magazine. Not only did you take my research out of context, you did so without my knowledge to support discriminatory goals that I do not agree with. What you wrote was not truthful and I ask that you refrain from ever quoting me again and that you apologize for twisting my work...
Finally, there is nothing in my research that would lead you to draw the stated conclusions you did in the Time article. My work in no way suggests same-gender families are harmful to children or can’t raise these children to be as healthy and well adjusted as those brought up in traditional households.
I trust that this will be the last time my work is cited by Focus on the Family.
And the other scientist whose research he quotes, Kyle Pruett, M.D. Yale School of Medicine:
Dr. Dobson, I was startled and disappointed to see my work referenced in the current Time Magazine piece in which you opined that social science, such as mine, supports your convictions opposing lesbian and gay parenthood. I write now to insist that you not quote from my research in your media campaigns, personal or corporate, without previously securing my permission. You cherry-picked a phrase to shore up highly (in my view) discriminatory purposes. This practice is condemned in real science, common though it may be in pseudo-science circles. There is nothing in my longitudinal research or any of my writings to support such conclusions. On page 134 of the book you cite in your piece, I wrote, “What we do know is that there is no reason for concern about the development or psychological competence of children living with gay fathers. It is love that binds relationships, not sex.”
Basically, Dobson's entire article, aside from the anti-gay bigotry, is factually inaccurate and plagiarized. So, the past month has seen 2 anti-gay Colorado mega-preachers come out of the closet, a religious right wacko tells us that soy beans make people gay, and now the anti-gay ringleader is a lying, plagiarizer? I hope this is momentum toward a collapse of the anti-gay movement.
Posted by Andy at December 14, 2006 9:20 PM
Corporations Court Gays, Pioneering Social Worker Passes Away:
The Pioneer Press looks at corporations actively recruiting LGBT workers. "When he was preparing for his job hunt last year,...
** Sep 24, 2007 **
Iran President: 'No Homosexuals in Our Country':
AmericaBlog has more....
** Sep 24, 2007 **
Get Ready for Another Marriage Amendment Push:
The social conservatives' buzz over the Iowa court decision striking down that state's Defense of Marriage Act continues in Minnesota...
** Sep 20, 2007 **
Religious Infringement Is Basis of Suit Against Minneapolis:
An organizational psychologist contracted by the Minneapolis Police Department filed a federal civil rights suit against the city of Minneapolis...
** Sep 19, 2007 **
South Central Minnesota Pridefest:
Last weekend (September 7-8, 2007) was South Central Minnesota Pridefest in Mankato, Minn, and it was a good example of...
** Sep 18, 2007 **
ACLU Comes to the Aid of Sen. Craig:
The ACLU has filed a friend-of-the-court brief in support of Sen. Larry Craig's move to have his guilty plea to...
** Sep 18, 2007 **
Local Airport Restroom Becomes a Tourist Attraction:
The restroom in the Lindbergh terminal at the Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport where Sen. Larry Craig was arrested in June...
** Sep 17, 2007 **
As Iowa Shows, Marriage is Important to Both Sides of Debate:
On August 30th, a Polk County, Iowa, judge ruled that the Defense of Marriage Act in that state was not...
** Sep 15, 2007 **
Friday Music Video: Britney Spears:
The Today Show's Matt Lauer has the hard hitting report on Spears' performance at the MTV Music Awards, a performance...
** Sep 14, 2007 **
The Story That Won't Die: News Keeps Sen. Larry Craig in the Hot Seat:
Sen. Larry Craig's arrest in the now infamous Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport restroom continues to make news as the senator...
** Sep 11, 2007 **
Pam's House Blend
The Shane Life
Jesus' General
Damn Straight
Wayne Besen
AMERICAblog
5 o'clock bot
Keith Boykin
Andymatic
PageOneQ
Addy Free
Towleroad
Dan Renzi
Law Dork
Dunner
Zionide
Qweerty
Lloydletta
Boy's Brief's
Jasper Ridge
ExGayWatch
Margaret Cho
Good As You
Box Turtle Bulletin
Straight, Not Narrow
MN Campaign Report
A Bluestem Prairie
The Power Liberal
Minnesota Politics
Craig Westover
Dump Bachmann
Norwegianity
Pharyngula
Blanked Out
Minvolved
MN Publius
Blotter
Agonist
Atrios
WI No on the Amendment
Daily Kos
Andrew Sullivan
Talking Point Memo
Talk Left
Wonkette
Star Tribune
CityPages
Lavender Mag
Powered by
Movable Type 4.01
Syndicate this site (XML)
Andy Birkey is a participant in the Center for Independent Media New Journalism Pilot Program. However, all of the statements, opinions, policies, and views expressed on this site are solely Andy Birkey's. This web site is not a production of the Center, and the Center does not support or endorse any of the contents on this site.

"Andy is witty, funny, and gay and lives on Eleventh Avenue South." - Twin Cities Babelogue at CityPages
"Witty guys from Minnesota rock." - Dan Renzi
"Andy is proof that good things do come from the middle of the United States." - Fear This Factor
"Eleventh Avenue South is the most read gay Minnesota blog I know of." - Lloydletta's Nooz and Comments
"Andy is the center of the Minnesota (homo) blogosphere." - Opendoors
"I would most likely have an enormous crush if we didn't live appoximately one million zillion kilometres from each other; but we do, so I don't." - Surly Snobby
Comments
They are looking more and more ridiculous, and marginalizing themselves. Dobson isn't going to go away - he's got that radio show with a huge audience - and that gives him a huge platform.
At the same time, I don't agree with those who are writing Time Magazine asking them not to publish Dobson - in my opinion, publish his idiocy, but then publish responses.
Posted by: Eva Young | December 15, 2006 7:22 PM
The great folks at SoulForce have an online petition on their website to get TIME to fact-check the Dobson article and publish the results or possibly retract the story to be kept in line with their own journalistic credibility:
http://www.soulforce.org/petition/2
Posted by: Seth Johnson | December 16, 2006 2:28 AM
And, Eve: I don't think most people are writing asking Time to not publish Dobson, they're just asking that Time not publish articles or opinions that distort the facts. Over and over, the folks at FooF misquote research and bend truth in order to make it appear to be in their favor. Much like what Katherine Kersten does in the STrib, they just don't get their facts right. And Time should be held to a higher standard than that. I'm all for free speach. Speak your mind. But a publication like Time should not give voice to those who lie in order to make their points.
Posted by: Seth Johnson | December 16, 2006 2:31 AM
I could go both ways on that. It's kind of fun to see Dobson getting embarrassed by his dishonesty. I wouldn't say TIME purposefully let him misquote, but I secretly hope a little that they did. On the other hand, it really makes them look bad along with Dobson.
Posted by: Andy | December 16, 2006 10:47 AM
When an invited columnist lies in their article, isn't the hosting publication complicit in the lie by not setting the factual record straight with a retraction or a correction? Say what you like about your beliefs, but don't misrepresent the truth. Allowing columnists to bend the facts to the degree that Dobson is doing seriously undermines the journalistic and editorial credibility of an organization.
Dobson isn't the only one who should be embarrased by his dishonest words: Time should be embarrassed for printing them.
Posted by: Seth Johnson | December 16, 2006 12:06 PM
While I loathe Dobson, as a journalist (by training) I am slow to use the word "plagiarized"... If Dobson pulled the phrase off of his own website, they could very well be his own words which he has simply chosen to re-publish. That's not plagiarism, at least by my reading of it.
Posted by: Christian | December 25, 2006 2:36 PM